Expectations for the brand new Dune film from director Denis Villeneuve are sky-high after the discharge of a promising first trailer earlier this month. However anybody who’s seen the David Lynch model from 1984 is aware of that Dune is a tough ebook to adapt. Science fiction creator Rajan Khanna notes that the Lynch movie struggles to steadiness storytelling with exposition.
“To start with, the whole lot’s repeated 5 occasions,” Khanna says in Episode 432 of the Geek’s Guide to the Galaxy podcast. “To start with you get hit with these items so many occasions, and also you’re like, ‘OK. I get it. Simply transfer on with the story.’ After which the final a part of the film speeds alongside, and stuff is barely defined in any respect.”
The most important downside with the Lynch movie is that it tries to cram an almost 700-page story into simply two hours. Geek’s Information to the Galaxy host David Barr Kirtley is hopeful that the brand new model, which covers solely the primary half of the ebook, will fare higher.
“I simply don’t imagine that you could possibly make any type of respectable two-hour lengthy Dune film,” he says. “The very best hope can be to dramatically simplify the story and lower out half the characters. However the factor is, at its core Dune has such a well-known, archetypal story that in case you simplify it, you’re like, ‘Oh, this is rather like each different science fiction film I’ve ever seen.’ It’s the small print that make it particular, that make it stand out.”
TV author Andrea Kail hopes the brand new film will discover the darkish facet of its protagonist, Paul Atreides, one thing the Lynch movie emphatically did not do. “Watching it once more was very disappointing, as a result of I watched it now for the primary time after having learn the ebook and remembering precisely who Paul was,” Kail says. “So it was painful, really, to look at it this time and go, ‘Oh yeah, they actually botched the hell out of this one.’”
Regardless of all that, the Lynch film does have just a few good touches which can hopefully affect the upcoming movie. Science fiction creator Matthew Kressel admires Dune‘s units and costumes, in addition to its gifted solid. “The movie is price it simply to see Patrick Stewart charging into battle with a pug in his arms,” he says.
Hearken to the entire interview with Rajan Khanna, Andrea Kail, and Matthew Kressel in Episode 432 of Geek’s Information to the Galaxy (above). And take a look at some highlights from the dialogue beneath.
Rajan Khanna on Dune‘s voiceovers:
“The interior monologue is all in whispers, and I simply discovered the impact of that basically off-putting. It simply feels bizarre. It felt prefer it actually interrupted the move. I watched it with my accomplice, Elisabeth. She hasn’t learn the ebook or seen the film earlier than, and from the start she simply bounced off of it onerous, due to all of the exposition. And truly, as a result of the movie has psychological skills, at one level she was like, ‘Oh, is the whispering them speaking with one another telepathically?’ As a result of their mouths aren’t transferring however they’re making these noises. And I assumed, ‘Oh, I would suppose that if I didn’t know something about Dune and I noticed this.’”
Matthew Kressel on Jodorowsky’s Dune:
“[Jodorowsky] mainly put all of his concepts that he didn’t get to place in Dune into The Incal and The Metabarons, that are graphic novels, and they’re precisely as batshit loopy because it sounds. From an ordinary narrative storytelling standpoint, there’s no manner this may ever fly in a film, as a result of characters get out of hassle like, ‘Let’s simply open a gap within the material of the universe,’ after which simply do it, after which they find yourself in a totally completely different a part of the universe, and the story would utterly change. I can’t even describe it. If you happen to haven’t learn The Incal, give it an opportunity. As a result of it retains constructing on itself. If you happen to haven’t learn it, I completely advocate going out and studying all of them.”
David Barr Kirtley on the Dune ebook vs. the Dune film:
“Within the Lynch theatrical lower I assumed it really labored rather well with [Irulan’s] narration proper firstly, the place she talks in regards to the area navigators and so forth, as a result of a lot of that stuff is both not within the ebook or doesn’t get talked about till three-quarters of the way in which by way of the ebook. The fundamental setup of ‘the spice is effective as a result of it means that you can journey by way of hyperspace, you possibly can solely get it on Arrakis,’ a number of that stuff just isn’t very clearly defined in any respect, so it’s good to have all of it simply laid out for you within the first two minutes of the film. … I felt like I had a greater thought of what was occurring on this universe two minutes into this film than I did 250 pages into the ebook.”
Andrea Kail on Frank Herbert‘s themes:
“Individuals prefer to be informed what to do. Freedom of thought, freedom of selection, freedom itself—it’s a duty that lots of people simply don’t need. Individuals need messiahs, individuals desire a God, individuals desire a Huge Brother, individuals need any individual to inform them, ‘It’s going to be OK. Right here’s what you do and the whole lot will likely be fantastic.’ They need a savior, they usually additionally need any individual in charge when issues go improper, or to say, ‘Nicely, that’s simply what it’s speculated to be.’ It’s a manner of not taking duty. … [Herbert] was busting that delusion of the messiah, saying, ‘Your messiah, there’s a darkish facet to that too, and also you shouldn’t depend on them.’ And I feel that’s onerous for individuals to simply accept.”
Extra Nice WIRED Tales