Superhero stans have suffered a drought as COVID-caused movie delays dried up Hollywood’s stream of big-budget flicks. Whereas Disney’s WandaVision has stored the fandom satiated, new mission bulletins are nonetheless sure to trigger a frenzy — particularly once they concern arguably the largest hero: Superman.
Final week, information broke that J.J. Abrams is producing a Black-led reboot of the Kryptonian hero written by Ta-Nehisi Coates, an acclaimed social activist and creator of Black Panther comics. Followers have been ready for a Black Superman for years; Michael B. Jordan even attempted to get one off the ground with Warner Bros. in 2019. Though it lastly seems to be occurring, the similarities between Superman and the Black expertise have been current for the reason that hero’s inception.
A primary, reoccurring attribute of Superman’s heroic identification is the unwavering feeling of otherness. He is an alien who blends in with humanity, and is even accepted by them in occasions of triumph. But, he’s unfailingly reminded of his outsider standing when he fails to please the very society he dangers his life to uphold. Whereas most viewers can relate to this plight, having felt just like the odd man out at one time or one other of their lives, reimagining the person of metal as a Black man permits filmmakers to faucet into the lived stress of supporting a society that solely has a spot for you when it advantages.
“This new take allows Coates and Abrams to construct a Superman that is not an out-of-this-world character, however as an alternative a strong reflection of the each day existence of thousands and thousands of People.”
Admittedly, there may be nothing fallacious with a white Superman; I’m the primary to say that Henry Cavill was knockout casting for the position. Nevertheless, this new take allows Coates and Abrams to construct a Superman that is not an out-of-this-world character, however as an alternative a strong reflection of the each day existence of thousands and thousands of People — an existence that was painfully displayed throughout final yr’s Black Lives Matter protests. Because the world and the U.S. appear to be waking as much as the systemic inequality endured by Black and brown communities, Coates would do nicely to harness this momentum to rework Superman into an agent of illustration as an alternative of a run-of-the-mill savior.
It is usually worthy to notice that illustration and social commentary aren’t the one areas of exploration afforded to a Black Superman, as all elements of Black tradition might and needs to be utilized to provide a full-bodied character not restricted to trite tropes. How do his notions of serving Earth change when raised as a Black man in a systemically racist nation? Does he see vigilantes as a welcome various to perpetual over-policing, or does he forsake his group to develop into a hero for each man (aka white males)? These are the questions a non-marginalized hero might by no means discover onscreen, and needs to be the driving power of Superman’s inside narrative, not overdone stereotypes. (The one trope I’ll tolerate is a brief scene the place Superman jokes that he can masks his identification with a easy pair of glasses as a result of all Black folks look the identical, adopted by a wink from a random Every day Planet safety guard in on the joke.) Both manner, this story has the potential to be rife with progressive characterization and real-world politics on par with Ryan Coogler’s Black Panther.
If DC is not able to sort out the nuance of a Black hero, and is as an alternative casting a Black Superman to tout a shallow stab at range — which is what Cyborg actor Ray Fisher appears to imagine the transfer to be — then we do not want it. Not solely as a result of it could be a missed alternative packaged as a milestone for inclusion, however as a result of it merely would not be good. An amazing film forces its characters to bask of their feats and faults, locked in a continuing grapple with their driving power. The premise of a Black Superman preventing a canon villain to save lots of society with out point out of his ideas on whether or not this society is price saving would fail on all fronts of the story. If DC desires a easy story, keep on with a easy character: a white man who has no reservations about serving his nation, as a result of when he actually thinks about it, the nation has at all times achieved the identical for him.